Would The Real Heisman Candidates Please Stand Up
Depending on what network you watch, who you listen to or what you read you may have noticed that there are a handful of "Heisman Frontrunners" out there right now. Many feel that Colt McCoy lighting up the worst defense in the Big 12 made him the clear frontrunner going into the final week of play. Others believe that it's Alabama's Mark Ingram who can become the first Tide football player to bring home the hardware with a solid performance against Florida. Speaking of Florida there's still the Tim Tebow factor out there and with all due respect to McCoy the best performance by a quarterback last weekend belonged to the holy one. Still there are some who believe the efforts of the individual account for the award and not necessarily the prestige of the team. For that reason Stanford's Toby Gerhart, Houston's Case Keenum and Clemson's CJ Spiller are in the conversation.
Some would say that in a year where there is no clear cut leader in the Heisman race then there really may not be a legitimate candidate. I disagree. I think that this is the way the race should shake out. The Downtown Athletic Club should invite the following five guys to New York City with each having a legitimate shot of their personal accomplishments earning them the most prestigious award in college football.
Toby Gerhart, Stanford Running Back - 311 rushes/1736 yards (5.6 ypc), 26 touchdowns, 1/1 passing, 18 yards, 1 touchdown, 10 receptions/149 yards (14.9 ypc). What Gerhart has against him is the fact that his regular season ended last week with the win over Notre Dame while Ingram, Keenum, McCoy and Tebow have the national spotlight of conference championship games this weekend. Don't blame Conference USA, the Big 12 and SEC for this blame the Pac 10 for not manning up and playing a conference championship game. Gerhart has been amazing this season as the workhorse for the Cardinal and at this point would be my frontrunner if I had a vote. Unfortunately his accomplishments may be lost in the hoopla of this coming weekend's events.
Mark Ingram, Alabama Running Back - 221 rushes/1429 yards (6.5 ypc), 12 touchdowns, 28 receptions/246 yards (8.8 yps), 3 touchdowns. Ingram has fewer touches, yards and touchdowns than McCoy but his 6.5 yards per carry is insane and he has the stage of the SEC championship game against Florida in his favor. After being nicked up a bit last week a big outing against the Gators could be labeled as a gusty performance and provide him a "Heisman moment."
Case Keenum, Houston Quarterback - 412/584 passing (70.5%), 4,922 yards, 38 touchdowns, 6 interceptions, 49 rushes/120 yards (2.4 ypc), 4 touchdowns. If you're looking for the best quarterback in the country then here he is. Keenum also has one more game to pad his stats when the Cougars play East Carolina Saturday for the Conference USA championship. There's no reason why Keenum shouldn't be on anyone's ballot. Even the strength of schedule argument doesn't work here as he's led Houston to victories over two Big 12 and one SEC school.
Colt McCoy, Texas Quarterback - 310/432 passing (71.8%), 3,328 yards, 27 touchdowns, 9 interceptions, 111 rushes/368 yards (3.3 ypc), 2 touchdowns. McCoy has been exactly what the Longhorns have needed him to be. He's been a leader both on and off the field, he's been the experienced quarterback who wills his team to victory, he's been the face of the franchise so to speak and he's been the model citizen. All of these things factor in to the process, or at least they should, but the one thing that McCoy has going for him that no other candidate does right now is the idea that he somehow got robbed last season. Don't underestimate the power of the sympathy vote because McCoy is going to get a share of them.
Tim Tebow, Florida Quarterback - 162/244 passing (66.4%), 2,166 yards, 17 touchdowns, 4 interceptions, 193 rushes/796 yards (4.1 ypc), 13 touchdowns. Tebow's passing and rushing stats don't really stand out on their own but combined they become quite impressive. The question is, are they more impressive than any of the other guys on this list to which I must answer perhaps some but not all. Like Ingram, Tebow has the national stage in college football's game of the week and has the opportunity to sway votes. I believe that of anyone on this list Tebow needs a big performance Saturday because to this point of the season he's made it on name recognition and legacy more than anything else as far as the Heisman race is concerned.
0 recs |
22 comments
|
Comments
Heisman
I hate what the Heisman has become: the best player on the best team! That’s not what it’s about.
best Offensive Non-lineman player on the best team.
there….fixed it for you
If I had a vote I think I’d be leaning to Ndamukong Suh of Nebraska.
It hasn't
Tim Tebow was neither the best player nor on the best team when he was handed the Heisman.
by burntorangehorn on Dec 2, 2009 1:25 PM CST up reply actions
That's a little more accurate
However, Florida wasn’t even close to being one of the best teams that season. They lost three games before the Heisman ceremony took place, plus they dropped the bowl game to a pretty pedestrian Michigan team afterwards.
by burntorangehorn on Dec 2, 2009 2:09 PM CST up reply actions
My Point
My point is that Florida was #9 in 2007. That’s still ONE OF THE BEST TEAMS in 2007. The Heisman didn’t go from a team ranked #50, or so.
I ran all the numbers of the past 74 Heisman winners, on average, the Heisman winners came from an average ranking of 8.4! If you eliminate the highs/lows (#53 – Hornung from ND in 1956 and #1 – 7 times), the average is still 7.8!
Even in 1935, the first year of the Heisman, there were still 120 teams!
Really? #7?
Man, I had no recollection that they were ranked that highly. They should’ve been more like 15-20 at best before the bowl game, and possibly unranked after the bowl loss.
by burntorangehorn on Dec 2, 2009 10:13 PM CST up reply actions
Well he is the return of
the Christ-child….or maybe John the Baptist. Just ask any Gator fan, they will tell you Tebow has walked on water.
gag
(ok, maybe I’m a little sensitive to this as Florida has their watch parties at the same location OU has ours)
Saw an explanation of Carlos Dunlap's DUI on barkingcarnival.com:
“Tebow handed him a water bottle that he had accidentally turned into wine.”
by burntorangehorn on Dec 2, 2009 2:18 PM CST up reply actions
Heisman Numbers
I have only gone back 30 years, but in the last 30 years, in the final rankings after the season is over, the 30 teams that produced those 30 Heisman winners finished with an average rank of:
7.5!
http://homepages.cae.wisc.edu/~dwilson/history.html
http://www.heisman.com/index.php/heismanWinners
Wait to see how this weekend pans out... and, yes, Suh
… my guess is McCoy won’t have a pretty game (at least I’m hoping so) against Suh.
If Suh was a choice to vote for, I would have him as the leading candidate. Best DT I’ve seen in some time… sacks, pics, blocked kicks. And he’ll be the first pick in the NFL draft.
I wish Suh would get an invite. Plus he has the best first name, which I can’t even pronounce.
what's even more annoying
is how they’re trying to turn it into a career award this year to justify giving it to McCoy. He’s having arguably his worst year so now they’re going to change their “standards” and take into account his four years rather than just this one. They way they manipulate these things to fix the outcome is nothing new, but it doesn’t make it any less annoying.
1984 Heisman Voting
Jerry Rice finished #9 in the Heisman voting.
He quite possibly had the best single season numbers by any wide receiver EVER!
He sets records in 1984 for TDs (all NCAA divisions – 27), Receptions (112) and Yards (1,875)!
Just because he played for Mississippi Valley State University, he was overlooked. Granted, had he played for a better team, he may not have been thrown to as much, and not had those records.
But my point is, and hindsight is 20/20, don’t you think he quite possibly was the BEST PLAYER in ALL of College Football in 1984?!?!?
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2007/football/ncaa/12/12/jackson.rice/index.html
He was in double-coverage and EVERYBODY knew they were going to throw to Rice and he STILL put up those huge numbers!
BLAME THE PAC-10???????????
You are insane blaming the Pac-10 for not having a championship game. It is the ONLY conference that has round-robin scheduling (which is a far greater threshold for competitiveness than having a championship game). That means Pac-10 teams play only less ‘directional’ state university. Furthermore, six Pac-10 teams play this week, which should be a testament to Gerhart for having one fewer bye during the season.
McCoy will win
as consolation for not getting it last year. I would agree he is a great QB, but was he really at his best this year? It would’ve been more meaningful to him if he had won it last year.
Out of all the candidates, I’ve only seen Gerhart playing live and I can attest to how much firepower he infuses the Stanford team and the whole conference. Pac-10 finally has depth and respectability. And it’s not the conference’s fault that they don’t have enough D-1 teams for a championship game. Schools don’t want to dish the $ for athletic programs, especially with the budget crisis of Calif and little returns for the investment.
Tonight's Game...
…is essentially a conference championship; however, I do think all conferences should have a championship-style game.
Nick Saban Confirmed
Tracy Wolfson asked, “Should Ingram win the Heisman?”
Saban, “…he’s one of the best players on one of the best teams…”
Idiot!

by 













